2006-01-15

Never Trust a Wiki

On digg.com there is a link to the Xbox-Linux wiki. This wiki claims that Linux can run on an Xbox, sans modchip, and without the need to crack open the Xbox case.

All this, I've learned, is technically true.

On the exact same page in a big bold font, is a link to this wiki's step-by-step guide. Step #16? "The best and most flexible way to transform an Xbox into a Linux-only machine is to do the Hardware preparation. It requires opening the Xbox, and doing some very easy soldering."

Gotcha.

I'm not saying the site is flawed. I'm not even going to weigh in on whether or not it's a good idea to use a gaming console for such a purpose[1]. All I'm saying is that saying "no soldering" on the front page but turning around and saying "maybe some soldering isn't entirely a bad idea" further on in the step-by-step guide is patently disingenuous. The only advantage I see to doing this is...uh. Well.... Actually, I don't see any advantage to this, other than the basic "I'm running Linux on an Xbox; take that, Microshaft!" bragging right that will elevate your status at your local 2600 chapter.

This whole idea does present a worthwhile idea, though. Linux is free and Xboxes are cheap. So let's say you have a small amount of money and need some very cheap Linux machines. What's the least amount of money you can spend? Are there any networkable devices available that, when brand-new, are cheaper than an Xbox? I don't know.

[1] The Sony Playstation 2 can run NetBSD. Step one? "Install PS2 Linux". You be the judge of how good an idea it is to do this kind of thing.

No comments: